|
|
Player
|
Summary |
|
1
|
Jusin Cicollela (Eagles) *
Verdict: Guilty
Level 2 Striking
80 points
10% Addition for 1 Match penalty in 2011
Pleaded Not Guilty
No Deduction for Good Record
-80 points carried over from offence in 2011
1 Match with 68 points carried over |
Impact was at the low end.
The action was completely unnecessary and after the play had stopped |
| |
Chris Kane (Eagles) *
Verdict: Guilty
Level 1 Rough Conduct
125 Points
Loading 20% 1 Match in 2010 and 1 Match in 2009
Add 25 Points = 150
Deduct 25% for Guilty Plea
150 – 25% (37.5) = 112.5
1 Match with 12.5 Points carried over |
Chris Kane is guilty of rough conduct
– dangerous tackle as it was unreasonable in the circumstances.
The tackle was of an inherently dangerous kind and there is a second lifting action before bringing the player to the ground with force |
| 2 |
Nil |
|
| 3 |
Natale Caruso (West)
Charge: Forceful Front on Contact
Verdict: Not Guilty |
|
| |
Adam Grocke (Eagles) **
Charge: Striking
Verdict: Guilty
Appeal on guilt dismissed - Conduct downgraded to Reckless
Reckless – High Contact – Low Impact
Level 2 Striking – 125 Points
+30% for 3 Match Penalty in 2010
=162.5 Points
No Deductions for Good Record or Pleading Guilty
1 Match Penalty with 92.5 Carried Over
|
|
| 4 |
Michael Newton (Norwood) *
Charge: Striking
Verdict: Guilty
Impact – Low
Contact – High
Level 1 Striking 80 Points
25% deduction for Guilty Plea
No Deduction for Good Record (2011 & 2008 in VFL)
80 – 20 (25%) = 60
Reprimand |
The Incident Review Panel have viewed the Newton Report from the weekend and have found him guilty of Striking, please refer below:
Conduct – Negligent – “Newton’s intent was to spoil but he didn’t really have eyes for where the ball was and wasn’t really near the ball in the end hence the rating of negligent contact. |
| |
Ryan Williams (Central) *
Charge: Sriking
Level 2 Striking – 125 Points
25% Deduction for Guilty Plea
25% Deduction for Good Record
125 – 62.5 (25%x2) = 62.5
Reprimand |
“on the material before us we have been able to make a decision whereby we find Ryan guilty of striking player McNamara with a right fist to the head”
Conduct – Reckless
“it was reckless conduct in the fact that Ryan was retaliating to being pulled to the ground, however he should have been aware there was a likelihood his actions would result in a report”
Impact – Low
“information from the umpire and the video is evident that the impact was low as McNamara is able to play on immediately”
Contact – High
“after receiving information from the umpire (Michael Schramm) it is evident contact was made to the head” |
|
5
|
Nil |
|
|
6
|
Clint Alleway (North) *
Charge - Striking
Conduct – Reckless
Impact – High
Contact – High
Level 4 Striking – 325 Points
20% Addition for 2 Matches received past 2 Seasons
325 + 65 = 390
25% Deduction for Guilty Plea
390 – 97.5 = 292.5
10 Points Carried over from 2011 Offense
292.5 + 10 = 302.5
Clint has accepted 3 Matches with 2.5 Points carried over
|
|
| |
Jarrod Young (Port) *
Charge- Forceful Front on Contact
Conduct – Negligent –Impact – Low
Contact – High
Level 1 Forceful Front On Contact – 125 Points
25% Deduction for Guilty Plea
25% Deduction for Good Record
125 – 62.5 (25%x2) = 62.5
Jarrod has accept a Reprimand with 62.5 Points carried over.
|
|
| |
Ben Kane (Sturt) *
Charge– Forceful Front on Contact
Conduct – Negligent –Impact – Low
Contact – High
Level 1 Forceful Front On Contact – 125 Points
25% Deduction for Guilty Plea
25% Deduction for Good Record
125 – 62.5 (25%x2) = 62.5
Ben has accept a Reprimand with 62.5 Points carried over. |
|
| |
Mitch Sandery (Panthers)
Charge - Forceful Front on Contact
Verdict: Not Guilty |
|
|
7
|
Chris Knights (Eagles) *
Level 3 Striking – 225 Points
25% Deduction for Guilty Plea
Chris has accepted a 1 Match ban with 68.75 carried over.
|
Conduct – Intentional – “the incident occurred 40metres from the ball and the report was the second contact with the first being to the stomach”
Contact - High
Impact – Low – “the medical report was obtained from South and there was no injury from the incident” |
|
8
|
James Allan (North)
Charge: Striking
Verdict: Not Guilty |
|
| |
Ryan Ferguson (West)
Charge: Striking
Verdict: Not Guilty |
|
| 9 |
|
|
| 10 |
Adam Thomson (Sturt) *
Charge: Rough Conduct
Verdict: Accepted a one match ban from the Incident Review Panel |
|
| |
Angus Rowntree (Eagles) *
Charge: Forceful Front on Contact
Verdict: Accepted a one match ban from the Incident Review Panel |
|
| |
Justin Hardy (Central)
Charge: Rough Conduct
Verdict: Not Guilty |
|
| 11 |
James Bennett (North) *
Charge: Striking
Conduct – Intentional
Impact - Low
Contact – Body
Level 3 Striking – 125 Points
25% Deduction for Guilty Plea
25% Deduction for good Record
Total = 62.5 Points
Verdict: Accepted a reprimand from the Incident Review Panel |
“James chases down the Norwood player with the intention to strike the player as reported by the umpire” |
| |
Brett Backwell (North) *
Charge: Striking
Conduct – Intentional
Impact - Medium
Contact – Body
Level 3 Striking – 225 Points
10% Loading for 1 Match Penalty in 2011
25% Deduction for Guilty Plea
93.75 Points Carried Over from 2011 Incident
Total = 279.4 Points
Verdict: Accepted a reprimand from the Incident Review Panel |
Brett intentional strikes the Norwood Player to the stomach at the contest resulting in the Norwood player falling to the ground in discomfort” |
| |
Brady Dawe (Norwood)
Charge: Misconduct (Kneeing)
Verdict: Not Guilty |
|
| |
Daniel Kulikowski (Port)
Charge: Forceful Front on Contact
Verdict: Not Guilty
|
|
| |
Matt Suckling (Norwod) *
Charge: Umpire abuse
Verdict: Reprimand |
|
| 12 |
Lewis Johnston (North) *
Charge: Stricking
Verdict: has accepted a reprimand from the Incident Review Panel |
|
| 13 |
James Meiklejohn * (Port)
Charge: Striking
Conduct – Reckless
Impact – Low
Contact – High
Level 2 Striking – 125 Points
25% Deduction Good Record
25% Deduction for Guilty Plea
Verdict: has accepted a reprimand from the Incident Review Panel |
“James made late high contact to the eagles player with a swinging arm” |
| 14 |
Nil |
|
| 15 |
Jason Sutherland (Central) *
Charge: Rough Conduct
Verdict: has accepted a one match suspension from the Incident Review Panel |
|
| 16 |
Bryon Sumner (Eagles) *
Charge: Forceful front-on-contact
Verdict: has accepted a one match suspension from the Incident Review Panel |
|
| |
Ben Kane (Sturt)
Charge: Rough Conduct
Verdict: Not Guilty
|
|
| 17 |
James Gowans (Central) *
Charge: Striking
Verdict: Reprimand |
|
| 18 |
Ty Allen (Glenelg) *
Charge: Striking
Verdict: Reprimand |
|
| |
Kriston Thompson (North) **
Charge: Striking
Verdict: Guilty (1 match)
|
|
| |
Joel Tippett (West) *
Charge: Striking
Verdict: Guilty (1 match)
|
|
| |
Scott Bricknell (West) *
Charge: Striking
Verdict: Guilty (1 match) |
|
| 19 |
Clint Alleway (North)
Charge: Striking
Has been offered one match by the Incident Review Panel |
|
| 20 |
Jeremy Clayton (Port) *
Charge: Umpire Abuse
Verdict: Guilty - Reprimand
|
|
| |
Craig Parry (Eagles) *
Charge: Striking
Verdict: Guilty (4 matches)
|
|
| 21 |
Nil |
|
| 22 |
James Boyd (Central) *
Charge: Striking
Verdict: Guilty (2 matches) |
|
| |
Chris Kane (Eagles) *
Charge: Charging
Conduct – Intentional
Impact – High
Contact – High
Level 5 Charging – 550 Points
- 10% Loading for 1 Match ban in Round 1 2012
- 25% Deduction for Guilty Plea
- 12.5 Carried over from offense in Round 1 2012
Total – 466.25
Verdict: Guilty (4 matches)
|
|
| |
Luke Jericho (Norwood) *
Charge: Acting in a manner detrimental to the image, spirit and best interests of the League
Verdict: Guilty - Reprimand
|
|
| 23 |
James Bennett (North)
Charge: Rough conduct
Verdict: Not Guilty |
|
| 24 |
Lachy Button (Glenelg)
Charge: Rough conduct
Verdict: has accepted a two match suspension from the Incident Review Panel |
|
| |
Michael Clinch (North) *
Charge: Striking
Verdict: Guilty (2 matches)
|
|
| |
James Gowans (Central)
Charge: Striking
Verdict: Not Guilty
|
|
| Finals WK 1 |
Alan Obst (Central)
Charge: Striking
Verdict: Guilty (1 match) |
|
| |
Eddie Sansbury (Central)
Charge: Striking
Verdict: Not Guilty |
|
| |
Adam Hartlett (West)
Charge: Striking
Accepted 1 match for Striking from the Incident Review Panel
(225pts-25% Early guilty plea) |
|
| Finals WK 2 |
James Gowans (Central)
Charge: Umpire Abuse
Verdict: Guilty ($500 fine) |
|
| |
Ryan Williams
Charge: Striking
Verdict: Guilty (1 match) |
|
.jpg){kind=small}
