2012 SANFL League Reports
|
|
Player
|
Summary |
|
1
|
Jusin Cicollela (Eagles) *
Verdict: Guilty
Level 2 Striking
80 points
10% Addition for 1 Match penalty in 2011
Pleaded Not Guilty
No Deduction for Good Record
-80 points carried over from offence in 2011
1 Match with 68 points carried over |
Impact was at the low end.
The action was completely unnecessary and after the play had stopped |
| |
Chris Kane (Eagles) *
Verdict: Guilty
Level 1 Rough Conduct
125 Points
Loading 20% 1 Match in 2010 and 1 Match in 2009
Add 25 Points = 150
Deduct 25% for Guilty Plea
150 – 25% (37.5) = 112.5
1 Match with 12.5 Points carried over |
Chris Kane is guilty of rough conduct
– dangerous tackle as it was unreasonable in the circumstances.
The tackle was of an inherently dangerous kind and there is a second lifting action before bringing the player to the ground with force |
| 2 |
Nil |
|
| 3 |
Natale Caruso (West)
Charge: Forceful Front on Contact
Verdict: Not Guilty |
|
| |
Adam Grocke (Eagles) **
Charge: Striking
Verdict: Guilty
Appeal on guilt dismissed - Conduct downgraded to Reckless
Reckless – High Contact – Low Impact
Level 2 Striking – 125 Points
+30% for 3 Match Penalty in 2010
=162.5 Points
No Deductions for Good Record or Pleading Guilty
1 Match Penalty with 92.5 Carried Over
|
|
| 4 |
Michael Newton (Norwood) *
Charge: Striking
Verdict: Guilty
Impact – Low
Contact – High
Level 1 Striking 80 Points
25% deduction for Guilty Plea
No Deduction for Good Record (2011 & 2008 in VFL)
80 – 20 (25%) = 60
Reprimand |
The Incident Review Panel have viewed the Newton Report from the weekend and have found him guilty of Striking, please refer below:
Conduct – Negligent – “Newton’s intent was to spoil but he didn’t really have eyes for where the ball was and wasn’t really near the ball in the end hence the rating of negligent contact. |
| |
Ryan Williams (Central) *
Charge: Sriking
Level 2 Striking – 125 Points
25% Deduction for Guilty Plea
25% Deduction for Good Record
125 – 62.5 (25%x2) = 62.5
Reprimand |
“on the material before us we have been able to make a decision whereby we find Ryan guilty of striking player McNamara with a right fist to the head”
Conduct – Reckless
“it was reckless conduct in the fact that Ryan was retaliating to being pulled to the ground, however he should have been aware there was a likelihood his actions would result in a report”
Impact – Low
“information from the umpire and the video is evident that the impact was low as McNamara is able to play on immediately”
Contact – High
“after receiving information from the umpire (Michael Schramm) it is evident contact was made to the head” |
|
5
|
Nil |
|
|
6
|
Clint Alleway (North) *
Charge - Striking
Conduct – Reckless
Impact – High
Contact – High
Level 4 Striking – 325 Points
20% Addition for 2 Matches received past 2 Seasons
325 + 65 = 390
25% Deduction for Guilty Plea
390 – 97.5 = 292.5
10 Points Carried over from 2011 Offense
292.5 + 10 = 302.5
Clint has accepted 3 Matches with 2.5 Points carried over
|
|
| |
Jarrod Young (Port) *
Charge- Forceful Front on Contact
Conduct – Negligent –Impact – Low
Contact – High
Level 1 Forceful Front On Contact – 125 Points
25% Deduction for Guilty Plea
25% Deduction for Good Record
125 – 62.5 (25%x2) = 62.5
Jarrod has accept a Reprimand with 62.5 Points carried over.
|
|
| |
Ben Kane (Sturt) *
Charge– Forceful Front on Contact
Conduct – Negligent –Impact – Low
Contact – High
Level 1 Forceful Front On Contact – 125 Points
25% Deduction for Guilty Plea
25% Deduction for Good Record
125 – 62.5 (25%x2) = 62.5
Ben has accept a Reprimand with 62.5 Points carried over. |
|
| |
Mitch Sandery (Panthers)
Charge - Forceful Front on Contact
Verdict: Not Guilty |
|
|
7
|
Chris Knights (Eagles)
Level 3 Striking – 225 Points
25% Deduction for Guilty Plea
Chris has accepted a 1 Match ban with 68.75 carried over.
|
Conduct – Intentional – “the incident occurred 40metres from the ball and the report was the second contact with the first being to the stomach”
Contact - High
Impact – Low – “the medical report was obtained from South and there was no injury from the incident” |
|
8
|
James Allan (North)
Charge: Striking
Verdict: Not Guilty |
|
| |
Ryan Ferguson (West)
Charge: Striking
Verdict: Not Guilty |
|
Please note all reported League players found guilty by the Incident Review Panel on Monday will receive an offer which can be accepted by the Tuesday 9am deadline. If a player chooses not to accept the offer, he will front the League Tribunal on Tuesday night.
This page will be updated Monday with report details, then updated Tuesday evenings straight after the SANFL Tribunal, with the verdict.
* A player becomes ineligible for the Magarey Medal if he is found guilty for a reportable offence during the season.
** Decision was appealed
Tribunal System
100 points = 1 match ban, under 100 points = reprimand
Additions:
10% is added to your base points for every game you have been suspended for in the past 3 years.
Deductions:
Guilty plea: 20% Deduction
Good record: 25% Deduction (a player that has never been found guilty of an offence in the last 7 years)
|
